Put this out elsewhere last week , interesting exercise.
Pick your best 15 of the last 10 years but you can only pick one player from each club. Have a go
1 Cluxton (Parnells)
2 Davy Byrne (Olaf’s)
3 R.O’Carroll (Kilmacud)
4 Jonny Cooper (Fianna)
5 Jack Mc. (Clontarf)
6 James Mc (Ballymun)
7 Bryan Cullen (Skerries)
8. Fenton (Raheny)
9. Denis Bastick (Templeogue)
10 Flynn (Finns)
11 Kilkenny (Castleknock)
12 Diarmuid Connolly (Vins)
13 Kevin Mc (Jude’s)
14 Con (Cuala)
15 Bernard B (OPER)
2 Likes
1.Cluxton
2.Fitzsimons
3.McMahon
4.Cooper
5.McCaffrey
6.O’Sullivan
7.McCarthy
8.Fenton
9.MDMA
10. Connolly
11.Kilkenny
12. Mannion
13.B Brogan
14. Rock
15.O’Callaghan
Your numbering is askew and ya have two Cualas.
That’s very good @daddyo.
It’s a cruel thread. Pick Jamesy, no Deano, no Philly. Pick Bernard, no Alan. Pick Brian, no other Brian. Pick Con, no Mick Fitz. Pick Mannion, no Cian, no Rory. Pick Jonny, no Tomás Brady, no Murch.
Vins, Skerries, Jude’s, Parnells, Fingallians, Castleknock, Clontarf and Olaf’s all pick themselves.
1.Cluxton (Parnells)
2. Byrne (Olafs)
3. Fitzsimons (Cuala)
4. Cooper (Na Fianna)
5.Mc Carthy (Ballymun)
6. O Sullivan (Crokes)
7. McCaffrey (Clontarf)
8. Fenton (Raheny)
9. MDMA (Ballyboden)
10. Flynn (Fingallians)
11. Kilkenny (Castleknock)
12. Scully (TSS)
13 B Brogan (OPER)
14. Connolly (St Vincent’s)
15. Macmanamon (St Judes)
Cluxton
Cooper
Cian
Philly
Jamesie
Howard
Jack
Fenton
MDMA
Kilkenny
Brogan
Connolly
Mannion
Con
Bernard.
Like trying to choose between your children really. Have to find room for Howard. Not having Flynn and Dean makes me feel dirty but I’m sure they won’t care.
Player of decade is easy - James MacCarthy. IMO.
Edit; only noticing club thing now! Too late.
1 Like
Yeah, it’s the one per club thing that makes it so tough.
You realise you are giving culchies ideas here . 1 player per club . Only a matter of time before Donegal propose this unusual Dublin specific rule.
FWIW
Cluxton
Fitzsimmoms
Roc
Cooper
McCarthy
Cullen
Mccaffrey
Fenton
McAuley
Flynn
Kilkenny
Connolly
B Brogan
Andrews
Kev mac
And 3 ballymunners
Maybe MDMA for Denis - otherwise as good as it gets
Keeper is a tough one
Cluxton
Byrne
Cooper
Daly
McCaffrey
McCarthy
Lowndes
Fenton
MacAuley
Flynn
Connolly
Kilkenny
Mannion
Con
McManamon
By no means the best Dublin team possible. No fitzsimons Howard Small Rock osullivan Murchan. Wouldn’t have mcmanamon macauley lowndes or daly anywhere near my actual team of the decade.
Read the opening post
I did big man what’s the problem
Pick your best 15 of the last 10 years but you can only pick one player from each club
If he has Con 1 no Fitz.
Fenton - no Howard.
McCarthy - no Rock or Small.
Cooper - no Murch
Well ya that’s what I did. I meant that its strange picking a team without those players which I did.
Do you not like Plunketts? 
Sure what did those brogan lads ever do?
2 Likes
I remember the brother giving out about them after Alan went off injured v Tyrone in 08 very early in the game , “ do those fuckers take turns to do their hamstrings “ . An uncle of man ( @ Yodas Da) only accepted Alan was a good player post 2011 
. Me , I always thought they were great …