Walsh Cup 2019/2020

Rescheduled for Wednesday, January 8 according to the Laois Twitter machine. Venue & time TBC.

EB isn’t a fan of the Walsh Cup. Thinks it should be abolished. Even had a public spat with John Horan last winter over it, if memory serves. So maybe they’ll officially withdraw in the New Year. I dunno… :woman_shrugging:

His team haven’t played a game since last July, you’d Think he’d relish the chance of a semi competitive game or two before the league.

He’ll be missing the Rathdowney Errill contingent though & that’s at least 4/5 starters. With that many missing, it’s hard to see them batin’ a Dublin squad bent on revenge (and Carlow) this side of Xmas.

Maybe he doesn’t want to head into the New Year on the back of 2 bad beatings & ruin momentum for the league campaign?

I never understood that, he doesn’t have to enter if he doesn’t like it. Lots of counties don’t participate in the pre-season stuff and it is no big deal.

Surely you are not suggesting splitting Dublin into Coláiste Eoin and the rest?!!!

1 Like

Kind of agree with him . When does the carousel ever end for inter county players .

They key to the fixtures mess is to eradicate the prelim competitions , introduce a proper closed season and linking the national league to the championship and playing over a shorter time frame

Well entirely agree with that, been banging that drum for years but failing that we have what we have and surely it beats training.

Yeah, but if enough counties/managers pull out of it, they’d have no option but to cancel it really.

The competitions a county enter shouldn’t be decided by managers tho. The whole season needs to be reviewed, and to be fair they have come a long way recently, still a way to go.

If managers are entering their C squads, they are pulling out of it in all but name. Co boards can’t force them who to pick. Mind you, whatever about a C squad, Laois are lucky to even have an A squad these days.

1 Like

Why that?

Players leaving/not committing in droves over the past couple of years.

Calling it off at this stage is a bit disrepctful, I think…

Agreed, I’d booked my flights home from Sydney this for game.




Slightly odd that no reason given for the cancellation. Still scheduled to play Westmeath away the following weeeknd.

It seemed to be known to some extent this game wasn’t going ahead earlier than the official announcement. Could be some sort of protest at starting the IC season in December.

Do you think you could get the flight changed for the Westmeath game… a bit late now I suppose

But these are ‘pre’ season competitions, so don’t really come into the equation by definition. If teams want to play them, they should play them, and if they don’t, then don’t. If they didn’t exist, I suspect a lot teams would be playing challenge games anyway though.

I am not sure in general that reviewing the season in anyway would find a solution, because I suspect there is none. If you play the county championship off quickly to facilitate clubs you would kill the whole thing, the county championships is the life blood. If you make counties release players to play club all the time, it would take from the seriousness of the competition. Players can’t train towards two different goals at the same time.

I think the solution is more to do with choices then scheduling. If we make a choice, for example, of only make allowances for county players to play club championship, over say late August (for the majority of counties who will be out of the AI) Sept, October and November and ensure counties play away with other club competitions the rest of the time, there is no excuse for club players not to have games. Students who want to travel can do that, and be back for the championship.

The county set up can then find any format that works for them over February to end of August - which is enough time to play a league and championship, and mainly at a decent time of the year.